Author: david bancroft

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies September 15, 1972. vs. Montreal Expos at Veterans Stadium Montreal 3 Philadelphia 2 WP- Mike Torrez LP- Steve Carlton (20-8) HR- Bob Bailey, Ken Singleton; Willie Montanez Real Life: 9IP, 3ER, 1UER, 10H, 3BB, HR. W-(24-9) Replay: 7IP, 3R, 7H, 5K, 2BB, 2HR Carlton finally lost, after winning his previous…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies September 11, 1972. vs. New York Mets at Veterans Stadium Philadelphia 3 New York 1 WP- Steve Carlton (20-7) LP- Jerry Koosman HR- Roger Freed; Tommie Agee Real Life: 9IP, 4R, 8H, 5K, 4BB, 1HR. L-(23-9) Replay: 9IP, 1R, 4H, 9K, 1BB, 1HR. W-(20-7) Steve Carlton reached the twenty-win plateau,…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies September 7, 1972. vs. St. Louis Cardinals at Veterans Stadium Philadelphia 1 St. Louis 0 WP- Steve Carlton (19-7) LP- Al Santorini Real Life: 9IP, 1R, 9H, 9K, 2BB. W-(23-8) Replay: 9IP, 0R, 5H, 9K, 3BB. W- (19-7) For the first time this year, Steve Carlton has pitched back-to-back shutouts.…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies September 3. 1972. vs. Atlanta Braves at Atlanta Stadium Philadelphia 4 Atlanta 0 WP- Steve Carlton (18-7) LP- Jim Hardin HR- Willie Montanez Real Life: 9IP, 0R, 5H, 4K, 3BB. W- (22-8) Replay: 9IP, 0R, 8H, 8K, 0BB, WP. W-(18-7) Steve Carlton logged his fourth shutout of the year as…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies August 30, 1972. vs. Houston Astros at The Astrodome Philadelphia 7 Houston 4 WP- Steve Carlton (17-7) LP- Jerry Reuss HR- Joe Lis; Doug Rader Real Life: 6IP, 3R, 3H, 3K, 4BB. L- (21-8) Replay: 9IP, 4R, 7H, 3K, 3BB, HR. W-(17-7) Steve Carlton went the distance in this one,…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies August 26, 1972. vs. Cincinnati Reds at Riverfront Stadium Philadelphia 1 Cincinnati 0 WP- Steve Carlton (16-7) LP- Jim McGlothin Real Life: 8IP, 3R, 12H, 4K, 1BB, 1HR. W (21-7) Replay: 9IP, 0R, 1H, 13K, 3BB. W (16-7) Steve Carlton pitched one of his best games of the year, nursing…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies August 21, 1972. vs. Atlanta Braves at Veterans Stadium Atlanta 4 Philadelphia 2 WP- Phil Niekro LP- Steve Carlton (15-7) HR- Bill Robinson Real Life: 11IP, 2R, 7H, 10K, 3BB. L-(20-7) Replay: 7IP, 4R, 9H, 5K, 3BB. L-(15-7) Bill Robinson hit a two-run home run, in the bottom of the…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies August 17, 1972. vs. Cincinnati Reds at Veterans Stadium Cincinnati 2 Philadelphia 1 12 innings. WP- Pedro Borbon LP- Chris Short HR- Pete Rose Real Life: 9IP, 4R, 7H, 2K, 4BB. W- (20-6) Replay: 9.33IP, 1UER, 4H, 15K, 4BB, WP. ND-(15-6) This was another game in which Carlton was nothing…

1960 World Series Game 7 October 13, 1960 New York Yankees at Pittsburgh Pirates What happened in real life? This was the famous World Series game, in which Pittsburgh’s Bill Mazeroski hit a home run in the bottom of the ninth inning, to win the game for the Pirates, 10-9. What happened in my replay?…

Steve Carlton 1972 Philadelphia Phillies August 13, 1972. vs. Montreal Expos at Veterans Stadium Philadelphia 4 Montreal 0 WP- Ernie McAnally LP- Steve Carlton (15-6) HR- Hal Breeden Real Life: 9IP, 1R, 3H, 8K, 3BB, 1HR. W (19-6) Replay: 7IP, 4R, 8K, 9K, 2BB, WP, HR. L (15-6) The Phillies were shut out, 4-0, by…